"Calarco elevates Ordinary Days. It's worth seeing for the excellent performances and superb, striking staging. As he has showed in other memorable productions, he has a deft way of fashioning simple but powerful imagery out of ordinary objects. Craig Vetter's set design consists of little more than a couple of radiator covers for the actors to stand on and an antique mirror with a circular frame that the actors trace wistfully with their fingers, expressing the longing they can't state in words. The room is surrounded by curtains, which the actors draw aside to reveal windows—real windows, which look out on Sansom Street and Moravian Street. In the moonlight, the Rittenhouse Square neighborhood proves to be a suitable stand-in for Greenwich Village. Like so much of this production, it feels real."

-Talkin' Broadway